This means that the editor is now taking a decision on your paper based on the peer reviewer comments and his/her own opinion. If required, the editor may consult the editorial board at this stage. Show
Can a paper be rejected after major revision?Answer: Unfortunately, sometimes manuscript do get rejected after the second or even third round of revisions. This can happen due to multiple reasons such as: The authors might not have adequately addressed all the questions raised by the reviewers. Can a paper be rejected after minor revision?Sometimes a revised manuscript goes out to a new reviewer, so although the minor revisions may have been done in a thorough manner, the new may identify other issues with the manuscript, which might result in a recommendation to reject. What does editor decision Start mean?The status ‘Decision started’ indicates that the peer review process for your manuscript is complete and the paper is now with the editor. The editor is probably going through the reviews to arrive at a decision. Hopefully, you will be informed of the decision soon. What does awaiting editor-in-chief decision mean?The Editor-in-Chief (EiC) makes the final decision on manuscript, with the associate editor (AE) making the initial decision. … So, the present status may mean that the EiC now needs to make a decision based on the peer review comments or on the revised manuscript. What does under review mean Springer?I sent a manuscript to Springer. The status appears as ‘Under Review. … If the manuscript clears the internal check, it will be sent for peer review. If however there were status updates before this one (such as for the internal check), the manuscript has been sent for peer review. ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7u7PRZ6WerF%2Bau3DAxJyfaKCfrHq1u46wn5qsXZm8pr%2BMoqtmpZWWu26wxJygrKGfo3qxsc2doKefXw%3D%3D If you disagree or want more information about a decision we’ve made, you can ask for an explanation or apply for a formal review. Explanation of a decisionIf you want more information about a decision we’ve made, you can ask us for an explanation at any time. We may be able to sort out your concerns without needing a formal review. You can request a pause on debt repayments while you wait for an explanation of a debt decision. Once you’ve asked for an explanation, an experienced staff member will call you to explain our decision. We aim to contact you within 14 days. If we can’t reach you by phone, we’ll send you a letter asking you to call us for an explanation. You don’t have to pay for an explanation of a decision. Formal reviewYou can apply for a formal review of a decision we’ve made. You may want to apply for a formal review if you understand our decision but disagree with it. You don’t have to ask for an explanation first. When you apply for a formal review, an Authorised Review Officer (ARO) will review the decision. The ARO will:
You can also request a pause on debt repayments during a formal review of a debt decision. You don’t have to pay for a formal review. When there are formal review delaysWe aim to finish a formal review within 49 days. Some may take longer than this. It depends on the details of the review. We have a high number of formal review applications in the queue for processing. This means it may take longer than usual before we get to your application. If you’ve asked for a formal review, an ARO will attempt to contact you to discuss your review before they make a decision. There’s no need to call us to check on the progress of your formal review while it’s in the queue. How to pause your debt repaymentsYou can ask us to pause your debt repayments while we complete an explanation of our decision or a formal review. You can do this when you talk to us about the debt decision. The pause will generally be for 6 months. If your explanation or formal review takes longer than 6 months, you’ll need to contact us to extend your debt pause. When to apply for a formal reviewYou can apply for a formal review of a debt decision at any time for almost all of our payments. Debt decision time limits are in place for the following:
You should apply for a formal review of claim and entitlement decisions within 13 weeks from the date we tell you about the decision. You can still apply for a review after 13 weeks. If we change the decision, you may only get your entitlement from the date you applied for the formal review. There is a limited time to apply for a formal review for some payments. Read about formal review time limits for:
How to ask for an explanation or apply for a formal reviewYou can ask for an explanation or apply for a formal review by doing one of the following:
To use the form, fill in and return to us the Explanation or formal review of decision form. For ABSTUDY OR Assistance for Isolated Children decisions, use the ABSTUDY and Assistance for Isolated Children (AIC) Explanation or formal review of decision form. If your Centrelink online account is linked to myGov, sign in now to upload your supporting documents. Sign in to myGov You can also use the Express Plus Centrelink mobile app. Read our guide to uploading your Centrelink documents online. If you can’t give the form or supporting documents to us online, you can send them to us at: Centrelink Reply Paid 7800 Canberra BC ACT 2610 What you can do if you disagree with the Authorised Review Officer’s decisionIf you disagree with the AROs decision, you can apply to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for a review of the decision. You can ask us to pause any debt repayments until the AAT’s review is complete. The AAT is an independent tribunal. They can change decisions but only according to the law. They can only review a decision after an ARO has reviewed the decision. There are different process for reviews about:
When to apply to the AATThere are time limits for applying to the AAT to review the ARO’s decision. For Paid Parental Leave Scheme, you have 28 days from our ARO’s decision to apply for an AAT review. For all other decisions, you should apply for an AAT review within 13 weeks from when you receive our ARO’s decision. You can still apply for an AAT review after 13 weeks. However, if the AAT changes the decision, you may only be paid from the date you applied for the review. How to apply for an AAT reviewGo to the AAT website and follow their instructions to apply for an AAT review. After you submit an application, we’ll send the AAT a statement. It will contain the reasons for our decision and relevant documents. You'll also get a copy of our statement and documents. There are 2 levels of review by the AAT. You may disagree with the outcome of the AAT's first review. If you do, you may be able to apply for a second AAT review. You should make an application for a second AAT review within 28 days of receiving the first AAT review decision. Decisions made by the AAT are binding on both you and us. Either of us may appeal a second AAT decision to the courts, but only on a question of law. For some types of decisions, there may be an AAT application fee. We’re unable to assist you with the costs of pursuing a review by the AAT. The AAT is also unable to award you costs if you’re successful. We don’t ask you to pay our costs if you’re unsuccessful. What else you should knowLegal assistanceYou can choose to have your own legal representative if you apply for a review of a decision. Free advice and assistance is available from the following organisations:
Compensation claimsIn some cases you may be able to claim compensation. This is if you think we've made a mistake that has caused you a financial loss or other harm. You should explore options such as a formal review before you consider a claim. Does pending decision mean rejection?When the status of your article changes from "with editor" to "decision pending," it usually means that the editor has reviewed your submission and is now in the process of making a decision about whether to accept, reject, or request revisions to your article. How long does a pending editor decision take?Pending editor decision The Academic Editor is making a final decision about your paper. They will consider the latest version of the manuscript, as well as the completed peer review process. This manuscript status usually lasts around 1–2 business days. What is the meaning of pending decision?pending decision means that an application for planning permission or permission in principle has been made or is deemed to have been made and has not been finally disposed of; Sample 1. How long does a pending decision take in MDPI?One of the first stages in the publication process for any paper submitted to an MDPI journal is “pending review”. This is one how this status is explained. The Editorial Office has received the manuscript and it is being pre-checked. It usually takes 1–5 days. |
