Is social responsibility a voluntary obligation?

Badger Company Founder Walks the Walk

As a carpenter, Bill Whyte was always looking for a solution to his dry, cracked hands, especially in the harsh New Hampshire winters. After trying many commercial lotions that didn’t really work, Whyte experimented with olive oil and beeswax to come up with a soothing balm to help heal rough hands. Mixing up the concoction at home, Whyte came up with a product that seemed to work and was made from natural ingredients.

Originally called Bear Paw, the lotion became known as Badger Balm after a friend found a competing product already named Bear Paw. Whyte set up a production line at home to fill the tins. Soon he was pounding the pavement in the town of Gilsum, trying to sell the new product to hardware stores, lumber yards, and health food stores.

Fast-forward a little more than 20 years from his early days of experimentation, and Whyte (affectionately known as the “head badger”) runs W.S. Badger Company with the same goals and passions he started with back in the mid-1990s. The company uses only organic plant extracts, exotic oils, beeswax, and minerals to make the most effective products to soothe, heal, and protect the body. And the natural ingredients come from all over the world—for example, organic extra virgin olive oil from Spain, organic rose essential oil from Bulgaria, and bergamot oil from southern Italy.

Badger’s homey culture is no accident. In fact, in the early days, Whyte made soup every Friday for the small staff. Today, Whyte and family members, including his wife Kathy, chief operating officer; daughter Rebecca, head of sustainability and innovation; and daughter Emily, head of sales and marketing, all embrace the ethical and social principles of this family business that have made the company a success.

To reinforce the commitment of being socially responsible and demonstrating transparency, W.S. Badger Company became a Certified Benefit Corporation, or B Corp for short. This certification requires companies to meet rigorous standards for transparency, accountability, and social and environmental performance. (Benefit Corporations are discussed in more detail later in this module.)

Becoming a B Corp. has helped the company organize how it operates. For example, pay for the highest-paid full-time employee is capped at five times that of the lowest paid, which is now $15 an hour (more than double New Hampshire’s minimum wage); a portion of company profits flows to employees via profit sharing, and all employees participate in a bonus plan; and new parents are encouraged to bring their babies to work, a program that has helped foster a new style of teamwork for the entire organization, as well as increase employee morale. In addition, Badger donates 10 percent of its pre-tax profits annually to nonprofit organizations that focus on the health and welfare of children, matches employee contributions to charitable causes (up to $100 per employee), and donates an additional $50 to a nonprofit chosen by each employee on their birthday.

Badger staff, which now number more than 100, enjoy a living wage, great benefits, and a socially responsible work environment thanks to a visionary who found an eco-friendly way to soothe his rough hands and created an ethical business as part of his journey.

Questions for Discussion

  1. How does Badger’s approach to social responsibility help attract and retain employees?
  2. Does the company’s certification as a Benefit Corporation provide Badger with a competitive advantage? Explain your reasoning.

Sources: “Badger’s History & Legend,” “Babies at Work Policy,” and “2016 Annual Impact Report,” https://www.badgerbalm.com, accessed June 27, 2017; “About Badger,” https://www.bcorporation.net, accessed June 27, 2017; “Badger ‘Still In’ on Climate Action, Asks New Hampshire Businesses, State Officials, and Local Leaders to Join Forces in Honoring Paris Agreement,” http://www.prweb.com, June 22, 2017; Amy Feldman, “Badger Balm Creator Once Dismissed Being a B Corp as ‘Just Marketing.’ Now He’s a True Believer,” Forbes, http://www.forbes.com, May 9, 2017.

Corporate social responsibility refers to initiatives companies take to asses their effects on the environment and impact on social welfare. CSR is largely voluntary and there are no specific laws that govern it. However, companies self-regulate through setting their own social and environmental standards for the good of their stakeholders. Global guiding principles and reporting initiatives, where companies issue statements about their engagement in environmental and social welfare activities, are other sources of CSR regulation. Legislation guides CSR to a much lesser extent.

Self-Regulation

  1. Businesses are increasingly developing codes of conduct, environment, health and safety standards, best practices guidelines and socially conscious programs in a bid to become more socially responsible. Companies target their CSR programs towards their stakeholders, including employees, consumers and the surrounding community. Aside from establishing standards, companies engage in philanthropy, participate in creating shared value with their stakeholders and benchmark their CSR initiatives against that of other businesses in their industry to ensure the effectiveness of their efforts.

Reporting Initiatives

  1. Public performance reporting through global reporting initiatives, integrated reporting and rankings has had a great impact on raising the profile and expanding the activities relating to CSR. The Global Reporting Initiative, established in 1997, encourages businesses to report on their compliance with human rights and equality standards. Integrated reporting, where companies make their annual financial reports together with their CSR initiatives, is also starting to take hold. Rankings or ratings such as the Global Initiative for Sustainability Ratings 2011 that establish industry benchmarks for CSR are another form of governance for business social responsibilities.

Global Principles

  1. Global guiding principles requiring businesses to meet specific standards on environmental protection, health, safety and labor working conditions have been instrumental in directing company efforts in meeting their social responsibilities. The UN Global Impact, World Business Council for Sustainable Development Vision to Action, International Business Leaders Forum, International Chamber of Commerce Business Ethics Tools, UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights and International Labor Organization Tripartite Declaration of Principles Concerning Multinational Enterprises and Social Policy are all examples of global principles governing CSR.

Legislation

  1. Although there is no specific legislation governing corporate social responsibility, there are laws that touch on it. For example, the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010 requires public companies that trade on a major American exchange to report the use of conflict minerals in their products and also work force diversity statistics to ensure equality and sustainability. Changes in the federal tax code to encourage companies to make charitable deductions of up to 5 percent of their income have also served to foster business social responsibilities.

Is social responsibility an obligation?

Corporate Social Responsibility, or “CSR,” refers to the need for businesses to be good corporate citizens. CSR involves going beyond the law's requirements in protecting the environment and contributing to social welfare. It is widely accepted as an obligation of modern business.

Is CSR voluntary or compulsory?

Voluntary CSR is connected to convictions and commitment. It's something that comes from inside the company, with a desire to change things and create value. It has a psychological explanation: Mandatory CSR is imposed from outside the company and it may not be perceived as own.

Is social responsibility a moral obligation?

Focusing on CSR from a moral viewpoint implies that managers have a duty/obligation towards their stakeholders to act in a responsibly way. The moral duty to be socially responsible can be derived from religious or ethical principles of a moral philosophy.

Is CSR a voluntary concept?

It is a concept whereby enterprises integrate social and environmental concerns into their mainstream business operations on a voluntary basis. CSR goes beyond compliance with legislative requirements. It is a voluntary concept, which is led by business.